15 Best Eye Creams for Sensitive Skin That Actually Work!

The products curated for this article are independently chosen by the
editorial team. If you make a purchase through the links mentioned below, we may receive a commission. Check out our product
research & curation process

Wave goodbye to dull eyes and dark circles with the best eye cream for sensitive skin. No matter how much you take care of your skin, a little stress or a sleepless night instantly reflects on your eyes. Even at the slightest appearance of an under-eye shadow, we start hunting for hydrating eye creams for sensitive eyes. For those who wonder if eye creams are necessary, let us tell us – they are! Unlike the rest of your face, the dermis under your skin is highly sensitive and thin. It requires extra care and hydration to prevent sagging, fine lines, and wrinkles.

An eye cream not only moisturizes and softens the sensitive skin around the eyes, but also tackles issues like puffiness, dark circles, dryness, hyperpigmentation, and tired-looking eyes. Dr. Vanita Rattan, a Doctor in Medicine and Cosmetic Formulator, says, “We lose 1% of our collagen production from 21 years old onwards which leads to wrinkles around the eyes, so it is best to opt for eye creams that are slightly thinner and smoother but glide on easier around the eye area but also not something that’s so runny that it runs into your eyes. It is good to include two ingredients – vitamin A and vitamin C fat soluble because these penetrate the dermis and help to restore collagen.” With a plethora of options in the market, we decided to shortlist the best eye creams for sensitive skin for you to shop from.

15 Best Eye Creams for Sensitive Skin To Keep Dark Circles Away

Soothe and calm your dull sensitive skin with the Burt’s Bees Sensitive Solutions Calming Eye Cream. Developed with dermatologists, this eye cream for sensitive skin has numerous noted awards to its name. Enriched with a potent blend of oils, moisture-boosting humectants, and squalane that helps in enhancing and restoring skin’s moisture barrier, this formula reduces visible signs of redness. It is formulated with nutrient-rich botanicals and a blend of aloe vera and rich which calm irritated skin along with the goodness of 75 vitamins and minerals in this formula. This eye cream for sensitive eyes is free from all types of toxins such as SLS, petrolatum, petrolatum, and even paraben. It is also approved by the National Eczema Association.

Bid adieu to fine lines and dark circles with the VELAMO ADVANCED Retinol Eye Stick. This retinol-enriched eye cream for sensitive skin is a multi-treatment formula that promises you younger-looking, and well-rested eyes. Powered by a potent peptide complex, vegan squalane, astaxanthin along with retinol, this formula targets all the visible signs of aging. It is clinically proven to show effective results in less than a month and give you younger-looking skin. From hydrating, and brightening, to firming your skin, these eye creams for sensitive eyes eliminate crow’s feet and wrinkles while locking in moisture for suppleness.

CeraVe Skin Renewing Eye Cream comes with a peptide complex that visibly firms your skin and reduces the appearance of crow’s feet and fine lines. It is enriched with 3 essential ceramides – 1,3 and 6-II which aid in maintaining the skin’s natural barrier. Along with niacinamide which visibly smoothens the fine lines and boosts radiance, the formula also contains caffeine that visibly reduces under-eye puffiness. It is not only the best eye cream for sensitive skin, but even works for oily to dry skin, and acne-prone skin types. The formula hydrates your skin to diminish signs of aging while firming it and restoring the protective skin barrier.

The DERMA-E Hydrating Eye Cream is enriched with the potent properties of hyaluronic acid and green tea along with the powerful antioxidant vitamin E. Hyaluronic acid is known to be nature’s moisture magnet which helps deliver antioxidants and essential hydration to your skin cells. Green tea in this formula helps in preventing and shielding your skin from showing any visible signs of aging, while vitamin E protects the skin against free radicals. This potent eyelid cream for sensitive skin infuses your eyelids and under-eye area with a blast of hydration. It is further enriched with Pycnogenol which has antioxidant properties to tackle puffiness.

Packed with replenishing and hydrating properties, the RoC Multi Correxion Eye Cream awakens and elevates the skin around the eyes. This eye cream for sensitive eyes delivers three age-defying results – lifting, smoothening, and awakening your eyes. Enriched with peptides that firm and contour your eyes giving a lifting effect, infused with 1.5% hyaluronic acid, the formula visibly eradicates fine lines. While the caffeine in this formula depuffs your eyes and results in a more rejuvenated look around the eyes. With consistent use, this eye cream for sensitive skin fills the fine lines, and wrinkles, and diminishes the tiredness of your eyes.

Made with Avène Thermal spring water to soothe the sensitive skin around the eyes, Eau Thermale Avene Soothing Eye Contour Cream is a must-have! This lightweight formula provides intense hydration along with antioxidant protection. It decongests and helps in reducing the puffiness around the eyes. This eye cream for sensitive skin is enriched with calming chamomile and dextran sulfate which eradicate puffiness. It also contains hyaluronic acid that eliminates dehydrated skin and locks in hydration. With pre-tocopheryl, a rich source of photostable vitamin E, the formula is packed with antioxidants that protect your skin against free radicals. While the key ingredient – Avène Thermal spring water is clinically proven with 150 studies to calm, soften, and soothe hypersensitive skin.

Packed with the goodness of eight peptides, the Drunk Elephant C-Tango Multivitamin Eye Cream is a multivitamin cream with restorative properties. The formula is also enriched with five forms of vitamin C that aid in brightening your dull and uneven skin tone and makes it appear visibly firm. Meanwhile, the eight peptides help in rebuilding, strengthening, and reducing fine lines and wrinkles. To make the formula more potent, cucumber extract caters to help your skin look younger and well-rested. Along with the powerful combination of replenishing ceramides, antioxidants, and soothing actives, this eye cream for sensitive skin enhances natural radiance. It can be included in both AM and PM skin routines.

Give your tired under eyes some TLC with the Sweet Chef Turmeric + Vitamin C Booster Eye Cream. Packed with antioxidants and calming properties, this is one of the best eye creams for sensitive skin that works wonders by enhancing your complexion while reducing puffiness and dark circles. The formula is enriched with the goodness of turmeric which has antioxidant properties that enhance skin complexion and brightens the under eyes. It also contains probiotics to restore the skin’s microbiome, vitamin C, and ginger to diminish tired-looking skin. Ginger also has 40 antioxidant properties that cater to reducing signs of premature aging and fading hyperpigmentation.

Say goodbye to uneven skin tone and texture with Pond’s Rejuveness Lifting & Brightening Eye Cream. Featuring a retinol complex, the formula is known to smoothen your wrinkles, fine lines, and uneven texture. It is further powered by vitamin B3 which improves skin’s elasticity and visibly helps in giving a lifted and tightened skin appearance around the eyes. This eye cream for sensitive eyes has the goodness of blur technology that enhances and tightens your skin texture and tone. Perfect to boost hydration, this eye cream is suitable for all skin types and shows visible results within a few days of use.

When moisturizing meets anti-aging properties, you know it is a bomb combination! Tree To Tub Ginseng Green Tea Night Eye Cream is not just that, but so much more. Packed with hyaluronic acid’s moisturizing properties, and anti-aging properties from retinol, this best eye creams for sensitive skin is simply unmissable. With retinol being a stronger acid, it is prone to cause more damage to sensitive skin. But to balance it, the formula is enriched with vitamin E, along with other soothing organic botanicals. This pH-balancing formula eradicates under-eye puffiness and bags, along with all the signs of tiredness and dullness.

The First Aid Beauty 5 in 1 Age Delay Eye Cream is a youth-restoring, multifunctional eye cream that tackles 5 signs of aging and tired eyes. The cream targets 5 concerns like dark circles, fine lines and wrinkles, dryness, uneven skin tone, and loss of elasticity. This 5 in 1 formula is loaded with active ingredients that benefit to smoothen, brighten, hydrate, correct, and protect your delicate eye area. The eye cream for sensitive skin is enriched with peptides that are a chain of amino acids. The alpha-arbutin in this formula helps in boosting radiance and even toning your delicate skin around the eyes.

Featuring exclusive peptide action and rare extracts to smoothen fine lines, try out the Perricone MD Hypoallergenic Firming Eye Cream. The deeply nourishing eye cream for sensitive skin is formulated with olive polyphenols which is a phytonutrient found in olives and has antioxidant properties. It hydrates your skin while fighting visible signs of aging and is highly effective using post-cosmetic procedures. The formula is further enriched with hyaluronic acid that promises you plump and supple skin, thanks to its moisturizing properties. To enhance the eye cream further, squalane effectively absorbs into the skin and provides intense hydration, and nourishes the surface cells.

The Honey Girl Organics Face & Eye Crème is made with natural and organic ingredients, this eye cream for sensitive skin nourishes it to boost natural radiance. It is formulated with the antibiotic and antioxidant properties of honey which is also a natural antiviral and humectant. The formula also contains beeswax which is a powerhouse of over 300 skin-beneficial micronutrients. Moreover, the vitamin A and vitamin E from the organic olive oil hydrates, soothes, and repairs dryness and damaged sensitive skin. It also contains propolis which heals and repairs skin, bee pollen that evens skin tone, and royal jelly to reverse the signs of aging. This naturally formulated eye cream works seamlessly even under makeup.

Truly a cult favorite, the Bobbi Brown Hydrating Eye Cream is a highly moisturizing formula that instantly melts into the skin for a boost of nourishment. This formula preps the under-eye for makeup and leaves it feeling smooth, soft, and thoroughly refreshed. It’s formulated with the brand’s signature enriched mineral water blend that helps in hydrating, balancing, and reviving the skin. The formula is further enriched with squalane for hydration, along with jojoba seed oil and avocado oil for deep conditioning. Aloe vera and witch hazel extracts in this formula also help in keeping your skin supple for makeup application. This best eye creams for sensitive skin is formulated without any form of toxins.

The Kate Somerville + Retinol Firming Eye Cream is clinically proven to improve skin elasticity and reduce the appearance of lines and wrinkles. This eye cream for sensitive eyes visibly firms, hydrates, and brightens the skin around your eyes. Enriched with retinol and lesser sensitive bio retinol to combat signs of aging, smoothen texture and enhance skin clarity, the formula also reduces skin’s imperfections such as pores and dark circles. This blend mimics retinoids and fights against skin aging, boosts natural radiance, and firms the skin. This eye cream also has hyaluronic acid to boost hydration, lime pearl to loosen keratinized cells, and promote stimulation and renewal of skin cells.

These were some of the best eye cream for sensitive skin that promises to show effective results. However, knowing about the product isn’t enough. There are a few more factors to consider before buying an under-eye cream for the sensitive skin around your eyes. Keep reading.

How to Choose the Best Eye Cream for Sensitive Skin

The skin under your eyes is highly sensitive and you simply cannot use any product on it. While some under-eye creams are highly beneficial, there are others that are loaded with chemicals that could hamper your sensitive skin. So, before blindly picking any under eye cream that claims to be the best, consider these key factors to pick the best eye cream for sensitive skin –

Ingredients

Reading the label before buying any skincare product is a habit you need to adopt. When it comes to eye creams, there are a few key ingredients that are highly beneficial and should be in the formula you pick for visibly good results. For instance, look for caffeine as it boosts blood circulation and reduces dark circles. To make sure your eye cream tackles wrinkles, fine lines, and other signs of aging, make sure it has hyaluronic acid for a boost of moisturization. Vitamin B3, or niacinamide are also some of the key ingredients to look for. When it comes to sensitive skin, you cannot go wrong if you pick natural or organic ingredients. Look for ingredients like aloe vera, and cucumber extracts that calm your skin, along with colloidal oatmeal, or chamomile for soothing properties. Other ingredients to look for are green tea, vitamin C, vitamin E, glycerin, or rosehip seed oil as they lock in moisture and enhance skin’s elasticity.

Chemicals

To make sure your sensitive skin around the eyes is well taken care of, choosing products with chemical-free, natural, or organic ingredients is always a good idea. While most ingredients in eye creams are skin-friendly, still it is best to read the label before buying the product. Make sure there are no toxins or any other harmful ingredients. It should be free of alcohol, SLES, or phthalates. It is best to avoid exposing the sensitive skin around your eyes to chemicals that can lead to cause irritation.

Formula

The dermis around the eyes is thinner than the rest of your face, which makes it tender and sensitive. So, you need to make a wise choice and pick a mild formula, that does not clog pores, and is also allergy-tested. It should be highly hydrating and nourishing whilst being non-greasy. Make sure it is lightweight and glides smoothly on your skin and absorbs easily. Heavier eye creams may cause an oily texture and would be a hindrance if you plan on using makeup over it. Pick the best eye cream for sensitive eyelids that not only focuses on targeting one skin concern but is overall skin beneficial. It should cater to puffiness, dark circles, fine lines, and wrinkles, along with dryness, uneven skin tone, and tired eyes.

Easy to use

When you need to apply a certain product every day, you must consider its ease of usage. If the eye creams for sensitive eyes come in a container, make sure it is an airtight one. Products that are not in airtight contains are more prone to oxidization and don’t tend to last longer. As per our expertise, it is best to invest in tubes or rollers as it eliminates the chances of contamination. For instance, when you dip your finger in to scoop out the eye cream, you end up contaminating it. The bacteria or germs on your finger can lead to irritation for sensitive eyes. Also, look for an eye cream for sensitive skin that works seamlessly under the makeup base.

Conclusion

The best eye creams for sensitive skin are the ones that help in catering to various concerns like dark circles, puffiness, wrinkles, and fine lines. After our thorough trial and error, we discovered that the ones formulated with natural and organic ingredients are the safest bet. Those with sensitive skin should focus on eye creams that are allergy-tested, do not clog pores, and are free from all forms of toxins. Make sure it is also a dermatologist-tested formula and can be worn under makeup too. The above-mentioned list has various options that help in tackling all these concerns along with boosting hydration and visibly firming your skin. Happy shopping!

Contributor: Dr. Vanita Rattan, Doctor in Medicine and Cosmetic Formulator

Author BIO

• 

Anoushka is certified in Professional Skincare and is a Mass Media (Journalism) graduate from Mumbai University. As a More